Well, y’all had just a few opinions on my dining table! 😀 I haven’t quite gotten through the 520+ comments (I’m over halfway through them, and I will read every single one!), but the consensus seems to be (1) I need to ditch the farmhouse style table, (2) a double pedestal table is the better option, as is an oval table, and (3) the double pedestal table I have is better than the farmhouse table, but isn’t the best option because the pedestals are too ornate/overdone/bulky.
So that leaves me with two options. I can either make new pedestals to go on one of the existing tables, or I can buy a brand new table.
I’m open to either option, and I’m even open to splurging on a really nice table. We all have different definitions of splurging. For me, a splurge on a dining table would be anything that costs over about $1500, and I probably couldn’t bring myself to spend more than about $2500. But if I’m going to splurge on a dining table, I need to really love that dining table. I’m obviously not going to splurge on something I have to settle for.
And therein lies my biggest problem. I’ve looked at hundreds of dining tables online, and I can’t find any that both suit my needs (expandable up to at least 100 inches) and that I find attractive. I’ve come to realize that I don’t like anything overtly traditional, but I also don’t like anything too streamlined and modern. I like a happy medium.
So with that in mind, there are a few that caught my attention. My favorite is probably this one from E Custom Finishes.
I don’t particularly like the top, and it doesn’t extend, so that won’t suit me. But I absolutely love those pedestals!! I like that they’re not overly ornate, and they’re not exactly traditional in style. I would call those transitional in style.
This table comes in at a close second place for me.
Obviously, that one is more traditional, but it’s not overly ornate, carved, curvy, etc. I like the simplicity of the pedestals. I like the pedestals on the first table much better, but I do like that the pedestals on the second table don’t take up as much floor space.
This table also caught my eye. To be clear, I don’t like glass-top tables, and it wouldn’t work for me anyway since I need an extending table. But I do really like the pedestals on this table.
I think they’re too big and bulky for my taste, but I like the style quite a bit.
And that’s pretty much it. I kid you not. Out of hundreds and hundreds of double pedestal tables I looked at, on Pinterest, Houzz, various online stores (Pottery Barn and such), and on a general Google search, this pretty much sums up everything that I like.
So you can see why the idea of splurging on a brand new table that I love, while it’s a nice idea, probably isn’t going to happen? So far, I haven’t even seen a table that I completely like 100%. Either I like the bases, and dislike the table top. Or I like the whole table, but it’s the wrong size. Or its the right size for everyday use, but doesn’t extend.
But I’ll keep looking. I haven’t quite given up just yet. In the meantime, I might also try my hand at some DIY pedestal ideas.
Addicted 2 Decorating is where I share my DIY and decorating journey as I remodel and decorate the 1948 fixer upper that my husband, Matt, and I bought in 2013. Matt has M.S. and is unable to do physical work, so I do the majority of the work on the house by myself. You can learn more about me here.
I hope you’ll join me on my DIY and decorating journey! If you want to follow my projects and progress, you can subscribe below and have each new post delivered to your email inbox. That way you’ll never miss a thing!