Dining Chair Makeover Progress (And Why It’s A Bigger Project Than I Expected)

Y’all, I’m still working on the dining room chairs makeover. To be clear, I don’t even have two of the fabrics that I plan to use on the chairs yet. I haven’t even ordered them. But I had definitely expected to have the chairs stripped, sanded, primed, and painted by now. As a reminder, I found these chairs on Facebook Marketplace, and the price was really reasonable. The chairs are heavy and very sturdy, so the fact that none of the chairs needed repairs before I gave them a makeover was great.

But what I couldn’t see on photos in the Marketplace listing was that these chairs had a very thick, intentionally sloppy, and very textured factory finish on them, the intent of which was to give them an aged and almost Old World look.

I didn’t even notice it when I picked them up or got them home and into the dining room. I didn’t even notice it until I started sanding them.

And then when I started sanding them, I noticed something else. Not only was there a thick, sloppy, textured factory finish on them, but there was also a series of intentional dents that had been put into the trim all around the chair backs and seats.

You can see the areas where my sander didn’t even touch the finish around the edge because it was like someone took a hammer and put a dent into the wood to make it look aged and worn. Again, it’s that intentional Old World look, and you can tell it’s intentional because of the almost perfectly even spacing between them (which is one big reason I hate these “aged” factory finishes).

It wasn’t just around the backs, but it was also on all four sides around the seats.

Fortunately, there was none of that on the backs of the chairs.

If you know anything about me and my style, you know I do not like aged finishes. I don’t like my furniture to look aged, antiqued, or Old World. I don’t like dents, dings, scratches, or any other method used to give furniture an intentional aged look. I like my painted finishes to look new, fresh, and clean.

Needless to say, these chairs ended up being a lot more challenging than I had expected when I bought them. Initially, I weighed the option of using a solvent-base wood filler to fill in all of those dings and dents, but that seemed way more labor-intensive than what I wanted to do. Then I tried to talk myself into just ignoring those dents (since all the chairs were already sanded enough for primer) and living with them like that. But I just couldn’t do it.

So I ended up re-sanding all of these chairs again, and this time I started with 80-grit sanding discs on my sander and I sanded out all of those dents. I was a bit nervous about how much I had to take off in order to get those areas smoothed out, but it worked out just fine. Of course, once I had them all sanded out with the 80-grit sandpaper, I had to go back and sand the again with 220-grit. Finally, by 7:00 yesterday evening, they were ready for primer.

I just want to remind you that the foam and fabric that I left on the chairs will be replaced. I just left that on there to protect the thick cardboard that supports the chair backs because I didn’t want to remove that cardboard and take a chance on ruining it, and I didn’t want to get paint on it.

So that’s as far as I’ve gotten, and that’s why these chairs have taken so long to get to this point. They still need another quick sanding with 220-grit, and then I can finally get them painted today. But when I brought them inside last night, I was so excited to see just how great they’re already looking (if you can look past the black fabric and old foam).

I also still need to put the clear coat on the table, but I love seeing how this is all coming together.

I also wanted to share these pictures because I thought y’all would get a kick out of them. I don’t know if I’ve ever told you about my sweet Cooper and how I’m pretty sure he missed his calling. I’ve always thought that he should have been a drug-sniffing dog or a bomb-sniffing dog because he is obsessed with sniffing.

Any time I bring something into the house, I have to stop and let him sniff it. And then he’ll continue sniffing until he’s satisfied. He does this with every person who walks through the door, every item I bring into the house, and he sniffs me repeatedly throughout the day any time I stand still or sit down. So when I brought the chairs in, he started his routine, sniffing every chair until he was satisfied. It’s cute, but the boy sure does slow me down. 😀

Anyway, I am making progress, slowly but surely. Yesterday when I was working, I got a little discouraged at how long this room has taken me so far, and how much I still have to do. But when I sat down at my computer this morning and pulled up the pictures at the beginning of this post, I was actually very encouraged. I’ve gotten a lot done! I removed the shelves, repaired the walls, and painted the walls with my new favorite neutral wall color. I’ve sanded and painted the dining table. I’ve gotten the rug and most of the clutter out of the room. I’ve made a chandelier. And I’ve stripped, sanded, and primed the chairs. So I really have gotten a lot done in the room! I’m glad I went back to those older pictures so that I could remind myself that progress really is being made.

More About Our Breakfast Room

see all breakfast
room diy projects

read all breakfast
room blog posts

 

 

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

13 Comments

  1. Those chairs, even in their naked, stripped-down state, look fabulous! They
    look elegant with the table, but not stuffy.
    It is curious to me how much I love the ‘cathedral’ profile of the top but when I see that in a kitchen cabinet I’m totally turned off!!
    Now, go easy on yourself, you have so much to do in your everyday life that you must get done. I think your progress is fine; it’s not like you have a boss tapping his foot and watch!!

  2. I have been thinking how quickly you are getting everything done in this room. Taking apart, repairing, creating a fabulous light fixture, sanding, sanding again and again, picking out colors, fabrics, painting and painting. Not to mention researching and pondering art. Great job! It is already looking so pretty. BTW, it seems the worst rude critics have went away and it once again enjoyable to read comments. Blessings

  3. I love following along on all of your projects! I hope that you’ll do some in-depth tutorials on how to re-upholster those chairs. Mine are the exact same design and I’m very intimidated to attempt it, but I love the chairs – I just want different fabric.

  4. I was going to suggest some Durham’s water putty unti you said you’d sanded the faux dents off. It’s a lot of work either way. I’d says you’ve gotten a lot done in the room and it reminds me there are some projects I need to get a move on and finish.

  5. Cooper’s adorable curiosity expressed through sniffing reminds me of Ed Yong’s book “An Immense World”—there’s a lot about dog sniffing in there 😆. (It’s very good on audio—he narrates it. I borrowed it from my library.) You might like it!

  6. Our Bella is a sniffer also. She would be great working in an airport sniffing luggage.
    She could also be a death-sniffing dog in case of a disaster. But the minute a gun went off or something loud happened, she’d be out of there! Bella goes through our house sniffing for something to get into and carries it to the backyard, like shoes, socks, a Kleenex box, bathroom rugs, TV remotes. She has us trained to shut all the doors, pick up our shoes, put up the trash, and put the remotes away so we are happy when we get home.
    The painting that the computer generated for your dining room was lovely. Why not just make something that?

  7. Gosh, I think we all thought you are moving right along…you already have the wall done, the light done, and so many decisions made, and started work on the furniture, and researching the artwork – the list is huge. I have to say, the chairs look amazing. They will be special! I think Cooper is so cute…my pups both know if I have been petting one of the neighbor’s dogs! Our boy especially is all over me trying to see where I have been and who I saw! 🤣 Must be a boy dog thing. I noticed he is often right near wherever you are working!

  8. Give yourself some credit and grace Kristi, you do what you can when you can and you’re doing great! Things are coming along just fine, and I’m glad you saw that by going back and looking at your pictures. Of course it’s never as fast as we want it to! I’d like to make a suggestion, if you turn your table and chairs diagonal then everybody will have a view out the window and nobody will have their back turned toward the pantry. Someone suggested this to me before and I couldn’t believe what a difference it made, except mine concerned the front door. I highly recommend it, or at least try it and see how you feel.

  9. Are you leaving the chairs bright white, or is that just the primer? Not sure I care for the bright white with the table, so I hope it’s primer. Will you be covering the padded sections with a small print, or a solid? As for Cooper, my dog is the same way. Every Amazon delivery has to be thoroughly sniffed, on every side and corner! She will stick her nose in grocery bags as I’m bringing them in from the car…slows me down!!!